Poorly MacBook Pro
Submitted by David on Mon, 30/07/2007 - 18:04A few weeks ago I started having problems with the super-drive on my MacBook Pro. Basically, it was scratching (or should I say, severely gouging) any media that I inserted. I thought it was the drive, and phoned Apple who quite quickly told me that it could be repaired and my local repair centre in Ipswich.
Cool. Until I rang them up. They said, if it is physical damage then I would have to pay for the repair. This prompted a close physical inspection, which revealed that the slot on the front of the drive was slightly closed up, and this was what was doing the damage. Careful examination showed that the aluminium case was slightly buckled. Shit. I have carefully looked after this laptop, and at no point has it taken an impact that could have done this, and yet there it was – a sodding dent.
The Ipswich firm (not Apple, but a repair agent) told me that it would cost well over £200 for this. So, I didn’t do anything.
A couple of months later I can’t take not being able to use the drive anymore, so I arranged a consultation with an Apple Genius at the Manchester Apple Store – hoping that I was wrong about the physical damage that couldn’t have occurred.
The guy was good, very good. It was a pleasure to deal with someone who understood the kit well and had very good customer service training. Unfortunately, in the end it was still deemed as physical damage. This is my only beef, how did it happen?? I still don’t understand how the damage could have occurred and I raised my concerns about robustness of the aluminium case. Apple are convinced that the aluminium case lends excellent protection, and the guy showed me examples of machines that had received severe bashings, but were still working.
Deep down, I think a plastic case might be more likely to break, but would be cheaper to replace and more likely to be able to take a knock and bounce back to the original shape, whereas I suspect that the aluminium case would deform permanently under the same conditions.
Anyway, the repair is booked while I am on holiday, which solves the issue of whether I take the laptop with me!
tags: home computing repairs | 26 comments